The goblet of fire plot hole

Harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot the book that could legitimately be called the turning point of the series is packed with action, backstory and significant darkness. Goblet of fire is almost twice the size of the first three books the paperback edition was 636 pages. Apr 05, 2012 harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot. Ones the fate of barty crouch junior, who could presumably back up harrys story about voldemort being alive since he doesnt get shown getting kissed by a dementor. While it is established in the goblet of fire that the unforgiveable curses require. Did jk rowling ever reveal the huge plot hole that made. Harry potter and the goblet of fire plot hole showing 1. This is a small but interesting plot hole to consider.

Aug 09, 2017 this is the the biggest plot hole in harry potter. Harry potter and the goblet of fire plot hole showing 14 of 4. Doctor who just dug itself a bizarre harry potter plot hole. Goblet of fire is definitely work and i couldve done for a lot of cutting. This particular plot hole has had fans of the series scratching their heads for years. The contestants have to be above the age of seventeen, and are chosen by a magical object called the goblet of fire. Rowling routinely names goblet of fire as the hardest in the harry potter series to write. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is a fantasy book written by british author j. Til goblet of fire is much longer than the first three books because jk rowling unintentionally created a giant plot hole and had to spend the rest of the book trying to fix it. Six plot holes in the harry potter novels terry graves. Doctor whos latest episode dug itself a bizarre harry potter plot hole. Thats because, of the three events designed to test the mettle of each schools. Goblet of fire opens with a bunch of murders, which shows us right off the bat that j.

Armed with his trusty muggle camera, colin crops of everywhere and is constantly trying to get the best shot he can of harry. She said there needed to be a proper runup for the conclusion and rushing the complex plot could confuse readers. Now that hp and the goblet of fire has long since been. Biggest plot holes in harry potter business insider. During the yule ball, we know that the weird sisters perform at hogwarts. Rowling can speed through a year in under 300 pages. And while usually those unrealistic events are explained by inuniverse laws, there are times when we sit up, squint at the glimmering screen and go wait a minute.

Voldemorts plan to get harry to the little hangleton graveyard, while very engaging to read, is, in my opinion, way too unnecessarily convoluted from a. Did jk rowling ever reveal the huge plot hole that made her rewrite. At the end of the third task voldemort is ressurected and the death eaters feel their dark marks burning and join him. None of the staff of hogwarts or harrys friends ostensibly both interested in his welfare suggest he do anything other than walk into an incredibly obvious trap. So, fear not, you did not read goblet of fire needlessly. Goblet of fire is almost twice the size of the first three. Much of the plot of harry potter and the cursed child involves revisiting scenes from goblet of fire, with younger protagonists born long after these events travelling back in time in a misguided effort to change history and save cedric diggory which only leads to them damaging events in. Now, let me say that i adore her novels, which brim with rich characters, tricky plots, and marvelous, magical settings. Wb we all know how in harry potter and the goblet of fire, harry and cedric were transported to the burying grounds from hogwarts when they touched the triwizard cup. This one should also be a pretty familiar plot hole to you, as it is often mentioned among fans. After arriving at hogwarts after voldemorts death eaters made a debacle of the world quidditch cup, harry and the others learn of the triwizard cup competition. Feb 28, 2019 it must have been a big black hole indeed, because i can still find like fifteen black holes or more. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire that jk rowling had to fix. The triwizard tournament was held during harry potter and the goblet of fire as a way to bring together the schools of hogwarts.

This major plot hole in harry potter potentially affects. Most of us never even noticed the plot holes until about the fifth read through, and even then we just didnt care. Does anyone know what plot hole jk had to fix in the goblet of fire. Dont just list off the ones from mugglenet or another hp fan site just share with us what you believe are the biggest plot holes or mistakes in your opinion.

Fifty years prior, the town of little hangleton was shaken by the killing of the entire riddle family. This free synopsis covers all the crucial plot points of harry potter and the goblet of fire. Harry potter and the goblet of fire, the fourth book in the series, was published in 2000. According to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk rowling realised she had written her way into a massive plot hole. The working title had got out harry potter and the doomspell tournament. Aug 16, 20 i recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j.

What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half. Unless youre an obsessive nitpicker about every last detail, you should find this a satisfactory film version of goblet of fire. This is the the biggest plot hole in harry potter indy100. Harry potter and the goblet of fire the harry potter lexicon. Voldemorts plan to get harry to the little hangleton graveyard, while very engaging to read, is, in my opinion, way too unnecessarily convoluted from a practical standpoint. Harry potter plot holes that have never been solved the. It follows harry potter, a wizard in his fourth year at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the mystery surrounding the entry of harrys name into the triwizard tournament, in which he is forced to compete. Rowling and the fourth novel in the harry potter series. Did jk rowling ever reveal the huge plot hole that made her. For the first time, bookstores held midnight release parties. Were taking a look at ten strange plot holes from the series that were never resolved. I know there are a few theories of why the story played out like this but how did rowling herself explain it. Harry potter and the goblet of fire inciting event.

Harry is forced into competing after the goblet of fire is hoodwinked and must face off against dragons, merfolk, death eaters, magical creatures galore, and eventually the dark lord himself. Nov 20, 2017 5 of the biggest harry potter plot holes. What rowling eventually produced was a meticulous and comprehensive novel. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it. Here are 15 harry potter plot holes everyone should be talking about. On the wikipedia site and another site it says that jkr had to rewrite half of goblet of fire because she found a big plot hole in the middle of. Ive heard the reason this book is so long is because there was a plot hole that needed fixing.

The only reason given for harry participating is to lure out whoever put his name in the goblet. Goblet of fire contains an entire subplot about houseelf rights not even referenced in the films. What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half the book. Were taking a look at ten strange plot holes from the series that were. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same book. Movies often make us suspend our disbelief to take us on magical or futuristic journeys, where unicorns are real and humans have already explored more than just our solar system. How did jk rowling address the plothole in goblet of fire. Dec 24, 2018 at the end of the third task voldemort is ressurected and the death eaters feel their dark marks burning and join him.

In goblet of fire it s stated it was barty crouch jr. On the night of selection, however, the goblet spews out four names instead of the usual three, with harry unwittingly being selected as the fourth champion. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is part of the harry potter novels series, a good topic. The harry potter film franchise may have wrapped up back in 2011, but plenty of easter eggs and littleknown facts remain to be discovered. His camera should be totally nonfunctional while hes on school groundsbut somehow, colin is able to happily snap away. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled greg ladens blog.

Harry potter and the goblet of fire summary shmoop. Maybe not the most substantial in plot of the series, but it certainly has a high. Goblet of fire is a fun, exciting book, one which takes us deep into the world of witches and wizards and leaves us all set up for darker things to come. Harry potter and the goblet of fire summary the halfway point. Apr 18, 2018 unlike its predecessors, the film adaptation of harry potter and the goblet of fire is very different from the book necessitated in part because the book is almost twice the length of prisoner of azkaban. Aug 26, 2010 the plothole being how barty crouchmoody could have made any object into a portkey and therefore not have to go to the trouble of entering harry in, and making sure he gets through, the triwizard tournament. He put harrys name into the goblet of fire, and has. Harry potter adaptation induced plot hole tv tropes. It is possible, however, that the illustration is of. It must have been a big black hole indeed, because i can still find like fifteen black holes or more.

Please include any sources so i can rummage around online. Here is a list of six plot holes in the harry potter novels that you may not be aware of. Rowling stated that she knew from the beginning it would be the biggest of the first four. And goblet is twice that length and it didnt always feel justified. On the wikipedia site and another site it says that jkr had to rewrite half of goblet of fire because she found a big plot hole in the middle of writing. Was it just to manipulate neville into having the resources harry. Does anyone know what the series early draft plothole was. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled scienceblogs. The plot hole that ate a mother and father theleaky. Read on for fifteen of the biggest plot holes in the series.

Rowling said she knew from the beginning it would be the biggest of the first four. Mar 17, 2017 i have read this book at least six times, and there is one thing that sticks with me as a plot hole. However, a later revelation in goblet of firethe fact that muggle technology doesnt work at hogwartssuggests that colins hobby of photography is actually a major plot hole in the series. I have read this book at least six times, and there is one thing that sticks with me as a plot hole. This is not a plot hole, exactly, just highly unrealistic even for. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of harry potter and the goblet of fire and what it means. Harry potter and the goblet of fire ymmv tv tropes. Rowlings massively popular book series and its accompanying films are a gold mine of fun facts that you may have missed during your initial viewing. Harry potter and the goblet of fire novel mugglenet. Did jk rowling ever reveal the huge plot hole that made her rewrite the goblet of fire. Then i was teetering between goblet of fire and triwizard tournament. This weasley cousin was also the famous phantom plot hole that j. Im not botherin with her no more, i promise yeh that. So jkr told us in bbc newsround, 782000 interview there are two plot holes.

Harry should have been able to see thestrals at the end of goblet of fire. But the film manages to add another couple to the mix. I think we can pretty much deduce from jos interviews that she came across some major plot hole partway through the book and she fixed it. Keep reading to see the biggest plot holes in harry potter. Goblet of fire works well as a standalone film, as a film version of rowlings book, and is in my opinion quite easily the best potter movie yet. After one team wins, there are large amounts of drunken celebrations. Harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot hypable.

What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half the. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki. The triwizard tournament was designed to promote magical cooperation across europe and in harry potter and the goblet of fire, it was great for building bridges.

Harry potter and the goblet of fire has been listed as one of the language and literature good articles under the good article criteria. Cover the art for the cover of the original uk edition depicts harry at platform nine and threequarters wearing a gryffindor scarf, however, harry hasnt been sorted yet. One of the things i admire most about this series is the way j. But in harry potter and the goblet of fire, harry and cedric diggory grab the goblet during the triwizard tournament, which responds at their touch to take them to the graveyard where lord voldemort is waiting. She had to rewrite chapter 9, the dark mark, times. Goblet of fire no prize for the triwizard tournament. And please include anything else you want to, hprelated or not. Let me give an example from the fourth book in j k rowlings harry potter series, harry potter and the goblet of fire. The plan all of it this one should also be a pretty familiar plot hole to you, as it is often mentioned among fans. But dumbledore comes to know about this when harry tells him after escaping graveyard. While it is established in the goblet of fire that.

Sparknotes is here for you weve got everything you need to ace or teach. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire that jk. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled greg laden. Harry potter plot holes and questions explained time. On that note, his giving neville the herbology book over a cup of tea after scaring him with the spiders and cruciatus curse in class.

Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki fandom. Some of those celebrating were former disciples of. I have read this book at least six times, and there is one thing that sticks with me as a plothole. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire. Til goblet of fire is much longer than the first three books because jk rowling unintentionally created a giant plot hole and had to spend the rest of the book trying to fix it close 2. And why was an elaborate plan even needed in the goblet of fire. In the end, i preferred goblet of fire because its got that kind of cup of destiny feel about it, which is the theme of the book. Cover the art for the cover of the original uk edition depicts harry at platform nine and threequarters wearing a. So what are the biggest plot holes in the potterverse. One plot hole commonly brought up about harry potter is the presence of the time. I recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j. According to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk rowling realised she had written her way into a massive plot hole and had to go back and write her way out of it.

Rowling was writing the goblet of fire, she nearly gave up, as there was a huge plot hole she had trouble fixing. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is part of the harry potter novels series, a. You may argue that owls can only trace those who want to be traced or maybe he had some sort of protection on him. Harry potter and the goblet of fire helping writers become.

In book three, it is revealed that voldemorts lackey, peter pettigrew, has been hidden in plain sight for. Justifiably, kay was given an additional year to illustrate 2000s goblet of fire, a novel twice the size of its predecessor and a book that caused rowling herself much difficulty working at lightspeed against significant publisher pressure, a plot hole forced the author to rewrite a large proportion of the book. I have listened to the book for 15 years, many times each year, but. Below is a list of mistakes that occur in the harry potter book series, such as plot holes and typos. The triwizard tournament was held during harry potter and the goblet of fire as a way to. Not even some of the greatest movies are immune to. Okay, so the entire goblet of fire story is one big plot hole, book and film. Mafalda was lost as a result because the character was not carrying out the function she wanted it to. It must have been a big black hole indeed, because i. Unfortunately, it wasnt quite as effective at actually entertaining the people it brought together. Discussion according to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk rowling realised she had written her way into a massive plot hole and had to go back and write her way out of it. The very beginning of the book has harry, the weasleys, and a whole bunch of other wizards and witches attending a quidditch tournament.